Lexington Candy Shop Menu

1226 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10028, United States
$$$ Diner
(2556 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

Welcome to Lexington Candy Shop, a nostalgic diner located in the heart of Manhattan at 1226 Lexington Ave. This charming establishment is renowned for its comforting menu, blending classic American diner fare with delightful sweets.

One of the standout offerings is the selection of Tuna Melts, available with Swiss, American, mozzarella, or cheddar cheese, priced between $17.50 and $17.95. For those craving a lighter bite, the Toast and Muffins section features a variety of options, including the beloved Blueberry Muffin and Bagels with Cream Cheese.

Don’t miss their signature floats and made-to-order sodas, crafted to evoke a sense of nostalgia. Many customers rave about the traditional Coke served in a classic style, alongside the creamy banana split made with top-notch Bassets ice cream. Each visit feels like a step back in time, where the atmosphere is warm, inviting, and simply unforgettable.

Fruit Juice

  • Tomato Juice
    US$5.00
  • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

    Large 16 oz. Fresh squeezed to order orange juice.

    US$15.00
  • Fresh Squeezed Grapefruit Juice

    16 oz. Squeezed to order.

    US$16.00
  • Apple Juice
    US$5.00
  • Pineapple Juice
    US$5.00

Cereal

  • Cereal
    US$5.00

Grill Selections

  • Grilled Swiss Cheese
    US$11.50
  • Grilled Mozzarella Cheese
    US$12.50
  • Grilled American Cheese
    US$9.50
  • Grilled Cheddar Cheese
    US$10.50

French Toast and Pancakes

  • Cinnamon Raisin French Toast
    US$17.50
  • Walnut Cinnamon Raisin French Toast
    US$17.50
  • Banana Nut French Toast
    US$16.50
  • Chocolate Chip Pancakes
    US$18.50
  • Blueberry Pancakes
    US$18.50
  • Our Classic Pancakes
    US$15.50
  • Pecan Pancakes
    US$18.50
  • Strawberry Topping Pancakes

    Served with whipped cream.

    US$18.50
  • Our Classic French Toast
    US$15.50
  • Banana Pancakes
    US$18.50

Tuna Melts

  • Tuna Melt Swiss
    US$17.95
  • Tuna Melt American
    US$17.50
  • Tuna Melt Mozzarella
    US$17.95
  • Tuna Melt Cheddar
    US$17.75

Side Orders

  • Sausage
    US$9.50
  • "Heart Smart" Fries

    Air cooked, not fried

    US$6.00
  • "Heart Smart" Onion Rings

    Air cooked, not fried

    US$7.00
  • Sliced Tomatoes
    US$5.00
  • Cottage Cheese
    US$5.00
  • Bag Of Potato Chips
    US$1.50
  • Potato Salad
    US$5.00
  • Bacon
    US$9.50
  • Coleslaw
    US$5.00
  • Ham
    US$9.50

Clubs

  • Roast Beef With Swiss Cheese & Bacon Club
    US$23.60
  • Shrimp Salad With Bacon & Tomato Club
    US$24.05
  • Chicken Salad With Bacon & Tomato Club
    US$21.05
  • Chopped Egg With Bacon & Tomato Club
    US$21.05
  • Fresh Turkey Club With Bacon, Swiss Cheese & Tomato
    US$26.60
  • Ham With American Cheese & Tomato Club
    US$20.05
  • Bacon With Sliced Egg & Tomato Club
    US$20.05
  • Roast Beef Club
    US$23.05
  • Tuna Salad With Sliced Egg & Tomato Club
    US$21.05
  • Ham With Swiss Cheese & Tomato Club
    US$20.05
  • Fresh All White Meat Turkey Club
    US$25.60
  • Tuna Salad With Bacon & Tomato Club
    US$21.05
  • Chicken Salad With Bacon & American Cheese Club
    US$21.05
  • Lexington Special Club

    Roast beef, bacon, melted American cheese, fried egg, butter and Russian dressing.

    US$25.60

Hot Beverages

  • Decaf Espresso
    US$5.50
  • Decaf Cappuccino
    US$8.50
  • Double Espresso
    US$9.00
  • Decaf Tea
    US$3.50
  • Espresso
    US$5.00
  • Cappuccino
    US$8.25
  • Regular Tea
    US$3.20
  • Regular Coffee
    US$3.20
  • Hot Chocolate With Milk
    US$7.50
  • Hot Chocolate

    Served in 12 oz, with one refill.

    US$3.75
  • Assorted Herbal Tea
    US$3.95
  • Decaf Coffee
    US$3.50

Homemade Soup

  • Bowl Of Soup Of The Day

    Please contact the restaurant for today's selection.

    US$10.00

Basic Sandwiches

  • Roast Beef Sandwich
    US$17.95
  • Tuna Sandwich
    US$15.95
  • Peanut Butter Sandwich
    US$7.95
  • Fresh Sliced Turkey Sandwich
    US$21.50
  • Frankfurter Sandwich
    US$6.95
  • Chopped Egg Sandwich
    US$15.95
  • Individual Tuna Sandwich
    US$16.95
  • Swiss Cheese Sandwich
    US$15.95
  • Ham Sandwich
    US$15.95
  • American Cheese Sandwich
    US$8.00
  • Chicken Salad Sandwich
    US$15.95
  • Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich
    US$7.95
  • BLT Sandwich
    US$15.95
  • Chicken Breast Sandwich
    US$15.95
  • Fresh Shrimp Salad Sandwich
    US$18.95
  • Bacon Sandwich
    US$14.50

Lite Delights

  • Hamburger Platter

    Served on a plate with cottage cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and no bun.

    US$15.95
  • Chicken Breast Platter
    US$16.95
  • Chicken Fingers
    US$9.50
  • Cottage Cheese Salad Plate

    With lettuce and tomatoes.

    US$11.00

Eggs and Omelettes

  • 2 Eggs With American Cheese

    Served with your choice of toast or roll.

    US$14.00
  • American Cheese Omelette

    Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$17.60
  • 1 Egg With Meat

    With your choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with your choice of toast or roll.

    US$13.95
  • 2 Eggs With Bacon & American Cheese

    Served with your choice of toast.

    US$17.50
  • Swiss Cheese Omelette

    Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$18.60
  • 1 Egg

    Served with your choice of toast or roll.

    US$9.95
  • Cheddar Cheese Omelette

    Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$18.05
  • WW Favorite Greek Omelette

    One egg and two egg whites, feta, spinach, and whole wheat toast.

    US$19.50
  • Cottage Cheese Omelette

    Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$15.10
  • 2 Eggs With Meat

    With your choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$14.95
  • Greek Omelette

    Feta and spinach. Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$20.05
  • Fresh Spinach Omelette

    Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$18.60
  • Eggs With Diced Salmon Omelette

    Served with your choice of toast.

    US$20.50
  • 2 Eggs

    Served with your choice of toast or roll.

    US$10.95
  • Fresh Mushroom Omelette

    Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$18.60
  • Mozzarella Cheese Omelette

    Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$18.60
  • Feta Cheese Omelette

    Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$18.60
  • Cream Cheese Omelette

    Made with three extra large eggs. Served with your choice of toast.

    US$14.00

Green Salads

  • Traditional Country Greek Salad
    US$17.50
  • Chicken Caesar Salad
    US$18.00
  • Caesar Salad
    US$13.00
  • Tossed Salad
    US$9.50
  • Traditional Country Greek Salad With Chicken
    US$22.50
  • Lettuce & Tomato Salad
    US$8.00

Toast and Muffins

  • Blueberry Muffin
    US$4.50
  • Bagel
    US$3.25
  • Buttered Toast

    Choice of white, wheat, rye, or multi-grain.

    US$3.25
  • Bran Muffin
    US$4.50
  • English Muffin
    US$3.25
  • Cinnamon Raisin Toast
    US$6.50
  • Buttered Bread Roll
    US$3.25
  • Corn Muffin
    US$4.50
  • Cinnamon Raisin Walnut Toast
    US$6.50
  • Bagel With Cream Cheese & Smoked Salmon
    US$14.95
  • Cinnamon Toast
    US$3.75
  • Bagel With Cream Cheese
    US$4.95

Desserts

  • The Milkshake
    US$11.95
  • Ice Cream Soda
    US$11.95
  • Cake

    Please contact the restaurant for today's selections.

    US$9.95
  • Sundae
    US$13.50
  • Pie A La Mode

    Please contact the restaurant for today's selections.

    US$11.95
  • Sprite Float
    US$11.95
  • Ginger Ale Float
    US$11.95
  • Danish

    Please contact the restaurant for today's selections.

    US$5.00
  • Coca-Cola Float
    US$11.95
  • Cheesecake

    Outstanding, a light, delicate delight.

    US$9.95
  • Fresh Orange Freeze
    US$13.50
  • Ice Cream Dish
    US$9.00
  • Pound Cake
    US$4.00
  • Banana Split
    US$13.95
  • Toasted & Buttered Danish
    US$6.00
  • Brownie A La Mode
    US$9.50
  • Root Beer Float
    US$11.95
  • Pie

    Please contact the restaurant for today's selections.

    US$9.95
  • Fresh Creamsicle Freeze
    US$13.95
  • Cherry Coke Float
    US$11.95
  • Frosted Float
    US$13.95
  • Cake A La Mode

    Please contact the restaurant for today's selections.

    US$11.95
  • Malted Milkshake
    US$12.40
  • Egg Cream

    16 oz

    US$6.40
  • Ice Cream Cone
    US$7.50
  • Brownie
    US$7.50
  • Half Grapefruit
    US$5.00

Hamburger Haven

  • Bacon Cheddar Burger
    US$13.95
  • Bacon Cheeseburger
    US$13.75
  • Angus Sliders With American Cheese

    Three sliders.

    US$18.00
  • Burger
    US$10.95
  • Jumbo Bacon Cheddar Burger
    US$15.95
  • Turkey Burger
    US$12.95
  • Jumbo Mozzarella Burger
    US$14.95
  • Cheeseburger
    US$12.50
  • Jumbo Cheeseburger
    US$14.50
  • Mozzarella Bacon Burger
    US$14.75
  • Jumbo Burger
    US$12.95
  • Jumbo Lexington Butter Burger
    US$15.00
  • Jumbo Mozzarella Bacon Burger
    US$16.75
  • Jumbo Bacon Cheeseburger
    US$15.75
  • Bacon Swiss Burger
    US$14.25
  • Hamburger With Fried Egg
    US$14.00
  • Jumbo Swiss Burger
    US$14.75
  • Mozzarella Burger
    US$12.95
  • Swiss Burger
    US$12.75
  • Garden Burger
    US$12.50
  • Angus Sliders

    Three sliders.

    US$16.50
  • Jumbo Cheddar Burger
    US$14.75
  • Jumbo Lexington Butter Cheeseburger
    US$16.00
  • Bacon Burger
    US$12.50
  • Jumbo Burger With Fried Egg
    US$16.00
  • Turkey Burger With Swiss Cheese
    US$14.95
  • Jumbo Bacon Swiss Burger
    US$16.25
  • Cheddar Burger
    US$12.75
  • Turkey Burger With American Cheese
    US$14.50
  • Lexington Butter Cheeseburger
    US$14.00
  • Lexington Butter Burger
    US$13.00
  • Garden Burger With American Cheese
    US$13.50
  • Jumbo Bacon Burger
    US$14.50

Special Sandwich Treats

  • Fresh Turkey Sandwich Special

    Turkey, coleslaw, and Russian dressing.

    US$22.50
  • Lexington Sandwich Special
    US$23.50
  • Shrimp Salad Club Sandwich Special
    US$22.50

Breakfast Sandwiches

  • Fried Egg Sandwich
    US$7.45

Salad Platters

  • Chicken Salad Platter

    Served with lettuce, tomatoes, coleslaw and potato salad.

    US$19.50
  • Smoked Salmon Platter

    Served with lettuce, tomatoes, coleslaw and potato salad.

    US$21.50
  • Chopped Egg Salad Platter

    Served with lettuce, tomatoes, coleslaw and potato salad.

    US$19.50
  • Individual Tuna Platter

    Served with lettuce, tomatoes, coleslaw and potato salad.

    US$18.50
  • Sliced Hard-Boiled Egg Platter

    Served with lettuce, tomatoes, coleslaw and potato salad.

    US$15.00
  • Tuna Salad Platter

    Served with lettuce, tomatoes, coleslaw and potato salad.

    US$19.50
  • Fresh Shrimp Salad Platter

    Served with lettuce, tomatoes, coleslaw, and potato salad.

    US$22.50

Cold Beverages

  • Skim Milk
    US$4.00
  • The Fresh Lemonade

    Voted best in new York three times by the new York times. 12 oz.

    US$9.00
  • Fresh Iced Tea
    US$5.40
  • Bottled Water
    US$3.00
  • Fresh Orangeade

    12 oz.

    US$9.00
  • Fresh Lime Rickey

    12 oz.

    US$9.00
  • Fresh Iced Coffee
    US$5.40
  • Chocolate Milk
    US$5.00
  • The Golfer's Iced Tea

    Iced tea and lemonade. 12 oz.

    US$10.00
  • Soda

    12 oz.

    US$4.65
  • Iced Decaf Coffee
    US$5.50
  • Milk
    US$4.00